Language as a variable: English, Spanish, ethnicity, and political opinion polling in South Florida Article

Hill, KA, Moreno, DV. (2001). Language as a variable: English, Spanish, ethnicity, and political opinion polling in South Florida . HISPANIC JOURNAL OF BEHAVIORAL SCIENCES, 23(2), 208-228. 10.1177/0739986301232006

cited authors

  • Hill, KA; Moreno, DV

authors

abstract

  • This article argues that conducting public opinion surveys in Spanish as well as English is crucial to the study of the modern Latino electorate. Unfortunately, the conventional wisdom is to survey only in English because, so the argument goes, the validity and reliability problems raised by bilingual polling and translation do not make it worthwhile to conduct surveys in two languages. The authors challenge this assertion with evidence from six political surveys in Miami-Dade County, Florida, that were conducted in both English and Spanish. It is found that, had the conventional wisdom beenfollowed and the polls been conducted in English only, results would have been profoundly inaccurate and invalid. The authors further take advantage of bilingual survey research methodology and assess the level of difference between the survey responses of English-speaking and Spanish-speaking Latino voters, comparing the former to non-Hispanic White voters as well. It was found that, on average, English-speaking Hispanic voters gave sets of responses to different survey questions that were roughly equidistant between those of non-Hispanic Whites and Spanish-dominant Hispanics. The importance of these findings, not only for the survey research methods literature but also for assimilationist models of ethnicity, is assessed.

publication date

  • January 1, 2001

Digital Object Identifier (DOI)

start page

  • 208

end page

  • 228

volume

  • 23

issue

  • 2